Skip to main content

Table 5 Effects of immigrant status and region of origin on occupation and industry injury rates

From: On the differential impact of the recent economic downturn on work safety by nativity: the Spanish experience

Independent variables

Occupation injury rate

Industry injury rate

 

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7)

(8)

(9)

(10)

(11)

(12)

 

Spec.1

Spec.2

Spec.3

Spec.4

Spec.5

Spec.6

Spec.1

Spec.2

Spec.3

Spec.4

Spec.5

Spec.6

Foreign-born

156.70***

220.09***

140.61***

122.95***

  

10.11

−13.13

−32.46

−29.24

  
 

(58.597)

(90.106)

(57.171)

(31.897)

  

(60.539)

(98.861)

(67.930)

(25.146)

  

Years in Spain

 

−8.99***

−4.87***

−3.88***

−4.90***

−3.90***

 

−0.92

0.78

0.84

0.80

0.82

  

(3.186)

(1.831)

(0.904)

(1.844)

(0.921)

 

(2.954)

(2.019)

(0.745)

(1.989)

(0.731)

Spanish native tongue

 

−46.24**

−18.93

−2.54

   

−66.10**

−38.66**

−19.97**

  
  

(27.175)

(19.705)

(12.050)

   

(31.345)

(21.925)

(9.513)

  

Africa

    

201.33***

157.50***

    

11.06

−0.24

     

(76.882)

(46.989)

    

(41.200)

(14.489)

Asia

    

−40.67

27.11

    

−105.16***

−38.26**

     

(44.326)

(34.095)

    

(42.148)

(20.164)

Europe

    

171.41***

127.39***

    

19.86

−7.97

     

(53.472)

(26.405)

    

(56.162)

(19.114)

Latin America

    

137.54***

120.87***

    

−33.47

−29.33

     

(56.481)

(31.579)

    

(67.520)

(25.103)

Other origin

    

8.30

16.10

    

−64.58

−29.68

     

(49.361)

(33.961)

    

(40.910)

(21.904)

Male

  

228.05***

93.41**

227.66***

93.43***

  

220.81***

58.02***

220.85***

58.02***

   

(61.974)

(37.085)

(61.926)

(37.174)

  

(72.632)

(13.197)

(72.500)

(13.188)

Age

  

−8.98**

−3.31

−9.02**

−3.36

  

−2.98

−0.96

−2.98

−0.97

   

(4.455)

(2.690)

(4.469)

(2.700)

  

(2.306)

(1.131)

(2.308)

(1.130)

Age squared

  

0.03

0.01

0.03

0.01

  

−0.01

0.01

−0.01

0.01

   

(0.042)

(0.026)

(0.042)

(0.026)

  

(0.023)

(0.013)

(0.023)

(0.013)

Married

  

−3.20

−15.15**

−2.99

−15.03**

  

28.79***

12.86***

28.92***

12.87***

   

(11.958)

(8.948)

(11.901)

(8.937)

  

(7.960)

(2.657)

(7.839)

(2.622)

Less than primary

  

229.99***

181.12***

226.92***

178.07***

  

45.36

6.61

46.27

5.91

   

(65.824)

(42.673)

(64.124)

(40.926)

  

(46.200)

(7.200)

(47.153)

(7.551)

Primary

  

163.08***

117.09***

162.72***

116.62***

  

51.07**

7.79**

51.45**

7.73**

   

(40.808)

(26.993)

(40.487)

(26.714)

  

(27.941)

(4.449)

(28.120)

(4.491)

University

  

−290.27***

−228.21***

−290.21***

−227.97***

  

−113.81***

−24.59***

−113.94***

−24.59***

   

(47.156)

(34.538)

(47.145)

(34.522)

  

(41.488)

(7.847)

(41.456)

(7.860)

Temporary contract

   

128.18***

 

127.63***

   

−4.68

 

−4.78

    

(35.132)

 

(34.908)

   

(6.034)

 

(6.028)

Job Tenure

   

−0.15**

 

−0.15**

   

−0.07

 

−0.07

    

(0.056)

 

(0.056)

   

(0.048)

 

(0.048)

Regional FE

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Year FE

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Time Trend

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Industry/Occupation FE

No

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

Ind/Occ. Time Trend

No

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

Observations

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,491

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,490

663,490

R-squared

0.049

0.054

0.239

0.417

0.240

0.417

0.072

0.074

0.222

0.525

0.222

0.525

  1. Notes: Injury rates calculated per 10,000 workers. The sample includes only individuals aged 16 and older who are employed in the private or public sector, except for military personnel, and not self-employed. Regressions also include a constant term. Observations are weighted using the individual weights in the EPA. Standard errors are clustered on industry or occupation. Standard errors in parentheses. * significant at 10% ** significant at 5%; *** significant at 1% in one-tailed or two-tailed tests.