Skip to main content

Table 6 Regression models comparing earnings between Canadian-educated immigrant women and foreign-educated immigrant women with a university degree, 1991 and 2006 cohorts

From: International students, immigration and earnings growth: the effect of a pre-immigration host-country university education

 

1991 cohort

2006 cohort

 

Model 1

Model 2

Model 3

Model 1

Model 2

Model 3

 

Coefficient

Canadian-educated immigrants

0.290 ***

0.161 ***

−0.098

0.384 ***

0.425 ***

0.060

Years since the base year

0.108 ***

0.100 ***

0.099 ***

0.114 ***

0.147 ***

0.152 ***

Squared years since base year

−0.003 ***

−0.003 ***

−0.003 ***

−0.005 ***

−0.011 ***

−0.012 ***

Canadian-educated immigrants interacted with years since base year

0.004

−0.003

0.000

0.007

−0.054 ***

−0.044 ***

Canadian-educated immigrants interacted with squared years since base year

0.000

0.000

0.000

−0.002

0.004

0.004

Age in the base year

…

0.019

0.011

…

−0.081

−0.068

Age squared

…

0.000

0.000

…

0.001

0.001

Graduate degrees

…

0.215 ***

0.178 ***

…

0.092 ***

0.080 ***

Months of study in a year

…

−0.090 ***

−0.084 ***

…

−0.077 ***

−0.072 ***

French

…

−0.091

−0.084

…

−0.126 ***

−0.143 ***

Other languages

…

−0.246 ***

−0.250 ***

…

−0.193 ***

−0.191 ***

Atlantic region

…

−0.180 **

−0.125

…

0.060

0.052

Quebec

…

−0.210 ***

−0.183 ***

…

−0.277 ***

−0.221 ***

Manitoba and Saskatchewan

…

−0.239 ***

−0.218 ***

…

−0.044

−0.054

Alberta

…

−0.093 *

−0.095 *

…

0.164 ***

0.132 ***

British Columbia

…

−0.141 ***

−0.129 ***

…

−0.071 ***

−0.069 ***

Regional unemployment rate

…

−0.019 ***

−0.019 ***

…

−0.015 **

−0.019 ***

Other economic class

…

−0.123 ***

−0.091 **

…

−0.265 ***

−0.231 ***

Family class

…

−0.210 ***

−0.179 ***

…

−0.339 ***

−0.278 ***

Refugees

…

−0.209 ***

−0.182 ***

…

−0.509 ***

−0.434 ***

Low prior earnings

…

…

0.041

…

…

0.229 ***

Medium prior earnings

…

…

0.269 ***

…

…

0.529 ***

High prior earnings

…

…

0.722 ***

…

…

0.956 ***

Years of prior Canadian work experience

…

…

0.001

…

…

0.000

Years of Canadian study

…

…

0.017

…

…

0.000

Intercept

9.541 ***

9.668***

9.766 ***

9.598 ***

11.683 ***

11.016 ***

Source-country fixed effect

No

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

  1. Note: The model R-squared is 0.117, 0.200 and 0.213 in models 1, 2 and 3, respectively, for the 1991 cohort, it is 0.056, 0.179 and 0.204 in models 1, 2 and 3, respectively, for the 2006 cohort. Sources: Statistics Canada, 1991 Census and Longitudinal Worker File linkage; 2006 Census and T1 personal tax file linkage; Temporary Residents File, Immigrant Landing File and T1 personal tax file linkage; and Longitudinal Immigration Database
  2. … not applicable
  3. *Significantly different from reference category (p < 0.05), **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001